Analysis Paralysis

The blog tour for my recently released novel is winding down. It’s been a challenge to do it, but every one of these posts has been different, so that anybody following me all the way through will be spared the annoyance of reading a rerun. My latest contains an introduction to the men of Return to Longbourn, as well as a new excerpt. Don’t miss a stop at Barbara Tiller Cole’s Darcyholic Diversions, where I visited a couple of days ago. If you haven’t yet found your way on your own, here’s the link.


decisionsAs I told you two weeks ago, I’ve begun working towards getting my books into the audio format – very exciting, yes! But also a lot of difficult choices to make, important questions to decide. Which narrator would do the best job? What payment terms should I offer him/her? Should I sign on for an exclusive publishing contract with better royalties, or hold on to my rights? The pros and cons of each option have been chasing round and round in my mind for days to where I’m totally stymied. I think I’ve officially achieved the state of analysis paralysis.

Analysis paralysis – The condition of being unable to make a decision due to the availability of too much information, which must be processed in order for the decision to be made.

So, once again, I turn to my role model and ask what Jane Austen has to say on the subject.

On first perusal, her characters seem remarkably decisive. Marianne Dashwood made instant judgements about what she wanted, and Elinor never wavered about what was right and wrong (one guided primarily by sensibilities, the other more by sense). Elizabeth Bennet didn’t hesitate to reject Mr. Collins’s proposal, even though (as he scrupled not to point out) her other prospects were limited. Even Anne Elliot, despite the years of suffering it had caused her, proclaimed in the end that she had been right at age seventeen to submit to Lady Russell’s persuasion and break off her engagement to Captain Wentworth.

lady caherineBut, if you’re looking for someone who absolutely never doubted her decisions, Lady Catherine de Bourgh takes the cake: 

There was little to be done but to hear Lady Catherine talk, which she did without intermission till coffee came in, delivering her opinion on every subject in so decisive a manner as proved that she was not used to have her judgement controverted.

In Mr. Bennet, we find lack of good judgement, but no lack of confidence when deciding to allow Lydia to go with the Forsters to Brighton. Emma falls into this same category by virtue of her bad advice to Harriet to reject Robert Martin’s offer of marriage. Other standouts in the “bad judgement” classification are Lydia Bennet and Isabella Thorpe – for their monstrously poor taste in men – but here again we don’t read that they had any difficulty making up their minds on the subject.

In vain I have struggledNo, I could only think of one instance where someone in a Jane Austen novel truly agonized over a decision. That was when Mr. Darcy debated within himself if he should turn his back on his pride, his will, his reason, and his family obligations – all to offer for Elizabeth Bennet’s hand! Fortunately for her (and for us!), he finally came to the right conclusion.

“In vain have I struggled. It will not do. My feelings will not be repressed. You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you.”

So what has any of this to do with my current situation. Probably nothing. But, after a day of reading legal contracts and evaluating complicated royalty payment structures, this little ramble was a pleasant diversion. Tomorrow, I swear, I’ll face up to the business at hand and break through the log jam somehow. If all else fails, I may resort to the flip of a coin. Too bad I can’t call Lady Catherine; I’m sure she’d be happy to tell me what to do.

About Shannon Winslow

author of historical fiction in the tradition of Jane Austen
This entry was posted in guest blog post, Jane Austen, Jane Austen Quotes, Shannon Winslow, Shannon Winslow's writing, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Analysis Paralysis

  1. Ann A. says:

    Oh, but I think it does help in your current situation. Each of the personalities you visited here had very different ways of coming to a decision. Some snap and some prolonged well thought out decisions. Hmm, I wonder which you will use? I think you will be more like Darcy. Wishing you good decision making. I will not be like Lady Catherine and put in my two cents worth ad nauseam.

    • I am definitely a Darcy, in this case, Ann; I am suffering over the decision!

      • Karen Field says:

        This is my favorite reason for loving Darcy. He is not so proud that he can’t learn from the truth when it is spoken to him by someone who cares not how they can benefit from him and his name, property, wealth, and good ton status. The fact that he is bewitched by Elizabeth adds gravity to his suffering but he is the kind of person who, when being told he is not behaving like a gentleman finds it is the ultimate criticism and something he must wrestle with his conscience to correct. He does this not knowing if he will ever see her again in the whole of his life. Now that man suffered and for the best reasons. He becomes worthy of winning her love and she ends up doing the same thing, never allowing herself to hope that she may see him again or be someone he would propose to after her new connections with Wickham and the family’s disgrace by Lydia.

  2. It would be nice to go through life with Lady Catherine’s confidence in her opinions and decisions. On the other hand, no one really liked her, so maybe I’d rather be a little less sure but with friends around to help me (or mock me, if necessary) when I goof up.

    I’m intrigued by the audio books so I am looking forward to learning what you decide to do. It’s very exciting, and also intimidating, to see all the options available to writers.

    • Exactly, Violet – the options a wonderful, but daunting, at the same time. Sometimes I’m amazed that I’ve come so far out of my comfort zone. Proves I’m passionate about writing!

  3. Shannon, I think you’re forgetting the oh-so-indecisive Harriet Smith! Now there was a character with absolutely no idea what she should do…. I’m usually fairly confident of right and wrong, but when it comes to making decisions you can’t change, I have a problem. One reason I will never have a tattoo! Take your time and don’t make a decision until you feel confident!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s